Bethesda originally wanted Fallout 4 to be set in New York, but too many other games like Crysis 2 and 3 had the same idea: "You know what? Maybe New York's not the right call"

1. Games
2. RPGs
3. Fallout
4. Fallout 4

Bethesda originally wanted Fallout 4 to be set in New York, but too many other games like Crysis 2 and 3 had the same idea: "You know what? Maybe New York's not the right call" News By Scott McCrae published 21 January 2026

But there's disagreement over who actually chose Boston

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Bethesda) Share Share by:

• Copy link
• Facebook
• X
• Whatsapp
• Pinterest
• Flipboard
• Email

Share this article 0 Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google

Fallout 4 could've potentially been set in New York instead of Boston, but The Big Apple proved too popular as a video game setting at the time.

Fallout 4 lead designer and writer Emil Pagliarulo explains in an interview with the PC Gamer magazine, "We wanted to do something grand and American: that's New York for you." However, the New York plan was quickly abandoned by Bethesda due to the popularity of the region.

"At that time, other games were being set in New York, one of the Crysis games just came out, and that was set in New York, then there was another game," Pagliarulo explains. He doesn't mention the other game in question, but it's likely he could be talking about the Prototype games or Resistance 3, given they both released around the same time as Crysis 2 and 3 – which were both set in New York.

You may like

• Fallout 5's "obvious" setting would be New Vegas, says Fallout: London lead, but he'd rather the RPG went to Texas
• Ex-Bethesda artist hopes Fallout 5 is set down South, but echoes former GTA lead in thinking farther than that might "backfire"
• Fallout: London lead is "really worried" Fallout 5 will use Bethesda's proprietary Creation Engine

Pagliarulo recalls the team deciding, "You know what? Maybe New York's not the right call." So, that's how we ended up with Fallout 4 being set in the Commonwealth. However, he and Fallout 4 lead artist Istvan Pely have different memories of how Boston was chosen.

Pagliarulo says, "I didn't want to push for Boston, even though I thought it would be a great location," adding that Pely and director Todd Howard came to him with the idea. Meanwhile, Pely says, "I remember when it came time to do Fallout 4, Emil's like 'can we do it in Boston? Can we do my hometown.'" He adds, "I don't know, maybe he got a kick out of that, blowing up his hometown."

Fallout: London lead is "really worried" Fallout 5 will use Bethesda's proprietary Creation Engine

Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over. TOPICS Bethesda Game Studios Bethesda Softworks CATEGORIES Nintendo Switch 2 Xbox Series X PS5 PC Gaming PS4 Xbox One Platforms Nintendo Xbox PlayStation Scott McCraeSocial Links NavigationContributor

Scott has been freelancing for over three years across a number of different gaming publications, first appearing on GamesRadar+ in 2024. He has also written for the likes of PC Gamer, Eurogamer, VG247, Play, TechRadar, and others. He's typically rambling about Metal Gear Solid, God Hand, or any other PS2-era titles that rarely (if ever) get sequels.

Show More Comments

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Logout Read more Fallout 5's "obvious" setting would be New Vegas, says Fallout: London lead, but he'd rather the RPG went to Texas    Ex-Bethesda artist hopes Fallout 5 is set down South, but echoes former GTA lead in thinking farther than that might "backfire"    Fallout: London lead is "really worried" Fallout 5 will use Bethesda's proprietary Creation Engine    Explore the history of the Fallout games with some of the devs who helped bring the iconic RPG franchise to life    Bethesda reflects on 10 years of Fallout 4: "You have to accept the creative choices you make on every game"    Bethesda was scared of making Fallout 3, but by Fallout 4 it had chilled out: "we don't have to be so reverential now"    Latest in Fallout Fallout 3 "went hard on the gloomy despair of the post-apocalyptic world" to differentiate it from Oblivion    Fallout: London lead is "really worried" Fallout 5 will use Bethesda's proprietary Creation Engine    A single map inspired Fallout 3's lead designer to create the RPG's entire story    The very first Fallout 3 art was the box art, but the most difficult bit to create was the iconic Vault suit    Excitement for Fallout 3 and New Vegas remasters raised and subsequently dashed by Steam glitch    Fallout 5's "obvious" setting would be New Vegas, says Fallout: London lead, but he'd rather the RPG went to Texas    Latest in News Larian lead says Epic CEO's claim the EGS offers "better deals" to devs "doesn't sit well" after Alan Wake 2 lost sales    Ubisoft hits "major reset" button, cancels 6 games, delays 7 more, and confirms 4 new IP    Cyberpunk 2077 VR modder isn't ruling out making it free following DMCA, but says people are pirating it to "punish" him    Out of nowhere, Donkey Kong Country Returns HD gets updated with new content a year since launch    Ex MMO dev allegedly hacked 68 players for in-game gold worth over $700,000 and sold it for Bitcoin, UK court finds the gold legally counts as "property" and can be stolen    Crimson Desert has finally gone gold ahead of its March launch    GAME REVIEWSMOVIE REVIEWSTV REVIEWS

1. 1Looking for a good 2-player board game? This superhero adventure is worth suiting up for
2. 2Trails Beyond the Horizon review: "This JRPG's thrilling real-time and turn-based combat evolves Metaphor ReFantazio's hybrid battles, making up for a poorly paced adventure"
3. 3Scythe review: "This alt-history board game is still a gold standard for modern strategy"
4. 4Skate Story review: "A beautiful and unique skateboarding game with great, stylized visuals set in a grungy underworld"
5. 5Octopath Traveler 0 review: "The strongest entry in this retro-styled JRPG series yet, I love the greater focus on tactical battles"

1. 1Return to Silent Hill review: "Neither an impressive adaptation nor coherent enough to act as a standalone film"
2. 228 Years Later: The Bone Temple review: "The wildest and weirdest entry into the franchise yet"
3. 3Avatar: Fire and Ash review: "Still a technical marvel, with some of the year's best action filmmaking"
4. 4Five Nights at Freddy's 2 review: "We have waited two years for a Five Nights at Freddy's 1.5"
5. 5Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery review: "Brings Knives Out back to its roots for a sequel that's almost on a par with the original"

1. 1Starfleet Academy review: "It may feel a little different to what we're used to, but this is Star Trek through and through"
2. 2A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms review: "This Game of Thrones spin-off is a heartfelt and fun return to Westeros"
3. 3Stranger Things season 5 finale review: “Shows off both the best and the worst of Hawkins”
4. 4Stranger Things season 5, Volume 2 review: “All set up for a finale that has so much to deliver”
5. 5Fallout season 2 review: "A hell of a lot of fun despite being overcrowded and convoluted"