id Software's 2D platformers were making "10 times" more money than its early FPS games, and Doom might never have happened if the studio followed the easy cash

1. Games
2. FPS Games
3. Doom

id Software's 2D platformers were making "10 times" more money than its early FPS games, and Doom might never have happened if the studio followed the easy cash News By Scott McCrae published 2 February 2026

Adrian Carmack getting a fright playing Catacomb 3-D is to thank for Doom existing

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Bethesda) Share Share by:

• Copy link
• Facebook
• X
• Whatsapp
• Pinterest
• Flipboard
• Email

Share this article 0 Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google

Doom and Wolfenstein 3D may never have happened if a developer hadn't almost fallen out of his chair playing their poorly selling FPS Catacomb 3-D.

While Wolfenstein 3D is often considered the origin of popular FPS games before Doom then sent the genre into superstardom, neither were the first FPS that id Software made. Tank-based shooter Hovertank 3D was the studio's first dip into the genre, while Catacomb 3-D was the studio's first foray into a character-based FPS.

However, despite Wolfenstein and Doom becoming revolutionary titles that would define a genre, they might never have happened if id made more responsible financial decisions. id only made $5,000 on Catacomb 3-D – about "ten times" less than the studio's 2D platformer series, Commander Keen was making – but thankfully Adrian Carmack got a fright.

You may like

• FPS legend John Romero says Doom is "one of the great privileges" of his life on the game's 32nd birthday
• Doom creator's canceled game is now "much smaller," but it "will be new to people" in the same way Elden Ring was
• Fallout co-creator warns devs that adding more features will always make other parts of their games worse

"One of my more cherished memories of making Catacomb was Adrian almost falling out of the seat when he turned around right in the face of a troll," John Carmack recalls in John Romero's documentary on the making of Catacomb 3-D (spotted by PC Gamer). While this could have simply been a funny memory of development, it actually proved to be more pertinent than you'd think.

"This is where we could tell we're starting to get it," John Carmack explained, adding, "This is the future of gaming, rather than looking at the little sprites moving around on the screen and maybe getting tense. But it was the sense of shock. That was the first moment that locked into my mind that we were really onto something in this new genre and style of play."

Adrian Carmack defended himself, saying, "It just automatically sucked you in visually. You couldn't help it," adding, "That was just one of the craziest things in a videogame I'd ever seen. We definitely knew that we'd found a new game style, a new game type."

And despite Catacomb not becoming a massive hit, Romero recalls "One night, we talked about how Catacomb 3-D was just the beginning of a new way to play games, and that the future was 3D." He adds, "Within an hour, we had decided what our next game would be: Wolfenstein 3D, the grandfather of first person shooters."

Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

FPS legend John Romero says Doom is "one of the great privileges" of his life on the game's 32nd birthday

TOPICS id Software CATEGORIES PC Gaming Platforms Scott McCraeSocial Links NavigationContributor

Scott has been freelancing for over three years across a number of different gaming publications, first appearing on GamesRadar+ in 2024. He has also written for the likes of PC Gamer, Eurogamer, VG247, Play, TechRadar, and others. He's typically rambling about Metal Gear Solid, God Hand, or any other PS2-era titles that rarely (if ever) get sequels.

View More

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Logout Read more FPS legend John Romero says Doom is "one of the great privileges" of his life on the game's 32nd birthday    Doom creator's canceled game is now "much smaller," but it "will be new to people" in the same way Elden Ring was    Fallout co-creator warns devs that adding more features will always make other parts of their games worse    Fallout 3's VATS system almost didn't make it into the RPG, and Bethesda worried no one would even want to use it    After Morrowind and Oblivion, hardcore RPG fans didn't want Bethesda on Fallout 3    Fallout 3's VATS system helped compensate for Bethesda's lack of shooting chops    Latest in FPS Games Call of Duty is cracking down on cheaters ahead of season 2 with "major" anti-cheat measures for ranked play    Marathon is '90s futurism, according to Bungie lead, who says the shooter was "deeply inspired" by wild PlayStation ads    Steam hit Escape From Duckov gets official Escape From Tarkov collab bringing the two extraction shooter giants together    Highguard boss says "the toxicity is challenging," will "continue to ask" if The Game Awards reveal was right decision    12 Highguard tips and tricks for new Wardens to help your team run riot while raiding    Highguard gets its first major patch, dev says it "significantly" improves overall stability and reduces crashes by 90%    Latest in News The OG survival horror trilogy, Alone in the Dark, is free for a limited time    I need every developer currently making a Soulslike to stop what they're doing and add this handy feature from Nioh 3    Ubisoft fires 13-year Assassin's Creed veteran after suspending him for speaking out against return-to-office mandate    "What the f***" is Markiplier's Iron Lung movie doing earning $8.9 million in one night, wonders Iron Lung dev    Silent Hill 2 remake studio's new teaser isn't a comeback for infamous PS2 horror game Rule of Rose – "Nice guess"    Dragon Quest visionary Yuji Horii is getting his own RPG-style manga detailing his journey to creating the iconic JRPG    GAME REVIEWSMOVIE REVIEWSTV REVIEWS

1. 1This hidden role board game makes me feel like a puppet master, so Traitors fans should listen up
2. 2Cairn review: "This climber has a grip on me – even when it loses its footing with awkward systems, the challenge remains surmountable"
3. 3The Doom Arena Board Game is hell on Earth (in the best way) | Preview
4. 4This award-winning board game is a five star must-have
5. 5Code Vein 2 review: "This vampire take on Elden Ring almost works, but the dungeons themselves lack bite"

1. 1Return to Silent Hill review: "Neither an impressive adaptation nor coherent enough to act as a standalone film"
2. 228 Years Later: The Bone Temple review: "The wildest and weirdest entry into the franchise yet"
3. 3Avatar: Fire and Ash review: "Still a technical marvel, with some of the year's best action filmmaking"
4. 4Five Nights at Freddy's 2 review: "We have waited two years for a Five Nights at Freddy's 1.5"
5. 5Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery review: "Brings Knives Out back to its roots for a sequel that's almost on a par with the original"

1. 1Wonder Man review: "A low-key gem that's up there with the MCU's best"
2. 2Starfleet Academy review: "It may feel a little different to what we're used to, but this is Star Trek through and through"
3. 3A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms review: "This Game of Thrones spin-off is a heartfelt and fun return to Westeros"
4. 4Stranger Things season 5 finale review: “Shows off both the best and the worst of Hawkins”
5. 5Stranger Things season 5, Volume 2 review: “All set up for a finale that has so much to deliver”