Coolplayers
Technology

Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything

2026-03-09 13:00
941 views
Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything

American culture demands that pain be productive. Historian Kate Bowler explores how the obsession with finding meaning in suffering turns into what she calls “purpose monsters”: the need to make ever...

Big Think Home Open search Open main menu
  • Search What are you curious about? Popular SearchesCritical thinkingPhilosophyEmotional IntelligenceFree Will Latest Videos Latest Articles
  • Topics

    Philosophy

    • Ethics
    • Religion
    • Flourishing
    • Knowledge
    • Philosophy of Science
    • Philosophy of Art
    • Language
    • Political Theory
    • Identity
    • Meaning & Purpose

    Science & Tech

    • Physics
    • Biology
    • Aerospace
    • Health
    • Geology
    • Computing
    • Engineering
    • Energy
    • Biotechnology
    • Astronomy

    Mind & Behavior

    • Psychology
    • Neuroscience
    • Decision-Making
    • Mental Health
    • Consciousness
    • Emotional Intelligence
    • Personality
    • Relationships
    • Parenting

    Business

    • Entrepreneurship
    • Leadership
    • Finance
    • Marketing
    • Innovation
    • Strategy
    • Management
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Startups
    • Economics

    History & Society

    • History
    • Literature
    • Art
    • Music
    • Film
    • Progress
    • Culture
    • Sociology
    • Policy
    • Geopolitics
  • Latest
  • Videos Latest Videos A woman in a pink dress lies on the grass in a field, facing away and looking toward the distance. Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything with Kate Bowler A man sits on a chair in front of a white backdrop in a modern, brick-walled room with shelves and lights visible in the background. The block universe: a theory where every moment already exists with Jim Al-Khalili A man with short dark hair, wearing a dark t-shirt and smartwatch, gestures with his hands while standing in front of a plain white background. Why alien civilizations may bloom and die unseen with Brian Cox A woman with long blonde hair sits on a chair against a plain white background, wearing a tan jacket and gesturing with both hands while speaking. A look into the mind of someone without empathy with Abigail Marsh A man sits on a chair against a white backdrop, placed in front of the Pyramid of Giza in Egypt, under a clear blue sky. How experimental archaeologists are resurrecting our forgotten past with Sam Kean Illustration of astronauts working on a large spherical satellite or space station in outer space, with stars in the background. We’ve been looking for life. Here’s why we should look for intelligence instead with Sara Seager See All
  • Columns MINI PHILOSOPHY with Jonny Thomson" text on black background with icons of pathways, scales, and a bird. Mini Philosophy A philosophy column for personal reflection. X-ray galactic center Starts With A Bang An astrophysics column on big questions and our universe. A black background with the symbols "B | T" in a box on the left and the word "BOOKS" on the right, with the first "O" replaced by an open book icon. Books A literature column to feed your curiosity. Abstract image featuring a human silhouette filled with various medical and neural diagrams, with brain scan images in the background. A small figure is walking towards the center, symbolizing the long game. The Long Game A business column on long-term thinking. Strange Maps A geography column on history and society. The Well A collection of essays and videos on life’s biggest questions. 13.8 A column at the intersection of science and culture.
  • Classes Featured Classes A person smiling in a stylized collage with a keyboard, hands, and orange diagonal stripes in the background. Members 8 videos Cultivating the Conditions for Innovation Martin Gonzalez A Venn diagram with three overlapping circles showing a person's face, a handshake, and a waveform on a green background. Members 5 videos The Humanity of Leadership Simon Sinek Ethnographer and author A collage featuring climbers helping each other, a pink compass rose, and a smiling man in a suit, all with a muted color palette. Members 7 videos How to Lead With Integrity Steve Stoute Founder and CEO, UnitedMasters and Translation A grayscale photo of a woman with hoop earrings, set against an orange background and overlaid on a black and white abstract digital pattern. Members 6 videos Transform Your Organization with AI Daphne Koller Founder and CEO of insitro. A bald man wearing a dark blazer and black shirt smiles slightly against a plain light gray background. Members 10 videos Unlocking Your Team’s Hidden Potential Adam Grant Organizational psychologist and author A four-panel image: a serving tray, a key symbol, a smiley face, and a smiling man in the bottom right corner. The colors are muted purple and beige. Members 6 videos The Secrets of Unreasonable Hospitality Will Guidara Restaurateur and Author, Unreasonable Hospitality Browse
  • More
    • Newsletters
    • Monthly Issues
    • Events
    • Big Think+ Learning
    • Creative Studio
    • Advertise with Us
    • About
    • Careers
    • View our Twitter (X) feed View our Youtube channel View our Instagram feed View our Substack feed
Sign In Membership
  • My account
    • My Classes
    • My Account
    • My List
    • Early Releases
    • Sign Out
  • Membership
  • Latest
  • Topics Back
  • Videos Back Latest Videos A woman in a pink dress lies on the grass in a field, facing away and looking toward the distance. Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything Not every hard thing happens for a reason, says Duke historian and writer Kate Bowler. She explains how our need... A man sits on a chair in front of a white backdrop in a modern, brick-walled room with shelves and lights visible in the background. The block universe: a theory where every moment already exists Theoretical physicist Jim Al-Khalili explores why our sense of time may be incredibly misleading, including the idea that past, present,... A man with short dark hair, wearing a dark t-shirt and smartwatch, gestures with his hands while standing in front of a plain white background. Why alien civilizations may bloom and die unseen Brian Cox examines why, despite billions of stars and trillions of planets, we have found no evidence of other intelligent... A woman with long blonde hair sits on a chair against a plain white background, wearing a tan jacket and gesturing with both hands while speaking. A look into the mind of someone without empathy Abigail Marsh unpacks what defines psychopathy, how it differs from antisocial behavior, and why terms like “sociopath” only add confusion. A man sits on a chair against a white backdrop, placed in front of the Pyramid of Giza in Egypt, under a clear blue sky. How experimental archaeologists are resurrecting our forgotten past Sam Kean examines how rogue archaeologists are recreating the sounds, tastes, smells, and practices of the ancient past. Illustration of astronauts working on a large spherical satellite or space station in outer space, with stars in the background. We’ve been looking for life. Here’s why we should look for intelligence instead Thanks to modern tech, Earth is now considered a ‘detectable’ planet. Astrophysicist Sara Seager explains how this idea can lead... A man in glasses and a suit jacket sits indoors, gesturing with his right hand. Exposed brick walls, a window, and a lamp are visible in the background. The tiny transistors remaking our global order "The production of the silicon wafers that are used in the chip manufacturing process requires extraordinary levels of purity." Bald man wearing glasses and a peach shirt sits on a chair against a white background, gesturing with his left hand while talking. The biological necessity of boredom in the age of screens "I call it a tyranny of attention because there's so many demands on our attention coming from so many different...
  • Columns Back Columns MINI PHILOSOPHY with Jonny Thomson" text on black background with icons of pathways, scales, and a bird. Mini Philosophy A philosophy column for personal reflection. X-ray galactic center Starts With A Bang An astrophysics column on big questions and our universe. A black background with the symbols "B | T" in a box on the left and the word "BOOKS" on the right, with the first "O" replaced by an open book icon. Books A literature column to feed your curiosity. Abstract image featuring a human silhouette filled with various medical and neural diagrams, with brain scan images in the background. A small figure is walking towards the center, symbolizing the long game. The Long Game A business column on long-term thinking. Strange Maps A geography column on history and society. The Well A collection of essays and videos on life’s biggest questions. 13.8 A column at the intersection of science and culture.
  • Classes Back Featured Classes A person smiling in a stylized collage with a keyboard, hands, and orange diagonal stripes in the background. Members 8 videos Cultivating the Conditions for Innovation Martin Gonzalez A Venn diagram with three overlapping circles showing a person's face, a handshake, and a waveform on a green background. Members 5 videos The Humanity of Leadership Simon Sinek Ethnographer and author A collage featuring climbers helping each other, a pink compass rose, and a smiling man in a suit, all with a muted color palette. Members 7 videos How to Lead With Integrity Steve Stoute Founder and CEO, UnitedMasters and Translation A grayscale photo of a woman with hoop earrings, set against an orange background and overlaid on a black and white abstract digital pattern. Members 6 videos Transform Your Organization with AI Daphne Koller Founder and CEO of insitro. A bald man wearing a dark blazer and black shirt smiles slightly against a plain light gray background. Members 10 videos Unlocking Your Team’s Hidden Potential Adam Grant Organizational psychologist and author A four-panel image: a serving tray, a key symbol, a smiley face, and a smiling man in the bottom right corner. The colors are muted purple and beige. Members 6 videos The Secrets of Unreasonable Hospitality Will Guidara Restaurateur and Author, Unreasonable Hospitality
  • My Account Back
  • Sign In
  • Membership
  • More Back
View our Twitter (X) feed View our Youtube channel View our Instagram feed View our Substack feed Search What are you curious about? Popular SearchesCritical thinkingPhilosophyEmotional IntelligenceFree Will Latest Videos Latest Articles

This content is locked. Please login or become a member.

Become a member Login The Well Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything Not every hard thing happens for a reason, says Duke historian and writer Kate Bowler. She explains how our need for purpose turns suffering into a performance. A woman with long dark hair, wearing a yellow blazer and gold necklace, looks towards the camera with a neutral expression against a plain light background. Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything Kate Bowler A woman with long dark hair, wearing a yellow blazer and gold necklace, looks towards the camera with a neutral expression against a plain light background. Kate Bowler is a four-time New York Times bestselling author, award-winning podcast host, and Professor of Religious History at Duke University. Overview Transcript A woman with long dark hair, wearing a yellow blazer and gold necklace, looks towards the camera with a neutral expression against a plain light background. Why pain doesn’t need to teach you anything Kate Bowler A woman with long dark hair, wearing a yellow blazer and gold necklace, looks towards the camera with a neutral expression against a plain light background. Kate Bowler is a four-time New York Times bestselling author, award-winning podcast host, and Professor of Religious History at Duke University.

American culture demands that pain be productive.

Historian Kate Bowler explores how the obsession with finding meaning in suffering turns into what she calls “purpose monsters”: the need to make every loss, failure, or tragedy count for something. But not everything happens for a reason. And not all pain is a lesson.

Bowler argues that grief deserves the dignity of honesty, not reframing. Instead of rearranging the past to find meaning, she suggests asking a different question: What’s left? And what might still be beautiful?

KATE BOWLER: American culture in particular is obsessed with the idea that all pain has to be a lesson.

Purpose has become this cultural mania in which everyone needs to be doing something for a special reason. I call the obsession with purpose and its aftermath "the creation of purpose monsters." Purpose monsters are everywhere. Is this gonna work out? Is any of this a divine conspiracy to make me good?

We are itchy when we hear an unanswered question like that because it goes right to our material conditions, right to our fear, right to our ontological insecurity.

I think the idea that all pain has to teach us something is because spiritually we want an answer to the mystery. The mystery is, "why do bad things happen to good people?" We need an explanation for evil. And in the face of seeing anyone in pain, we want to be able to say, "I know why." But just because there's not a reason doesn't mean it's not meaningful.

Allowing ourselves the preciousness of the dignity of grief is both good and necessary. Beause when someone's telling you there's a lesson, it's as if they're saying, "I swear you didn't lose anything. Look around. It's all there." But we know in our hearts we're being lied to.

It's almost like that question just causes us to endlessly be looking backwards and, like, trying to rearrange the furniture of our past, when really we need a second to just say, "Alright, the floods came. What's left here for me to make something beautiful?"

Overview Transcript

American culture demands that pain be productive.

Historian Kate Bowler explores how the obsession with finding meaning in suffering turns into what she calls “purpose monsters”: the need to make every loss, failure, or tragedy count for something. But not everything happens for a reason. And not all pain is a lesson.

Bowler argues that grief deserves the dignity of honesty, not reframing. Instead of rearranging the past to find meaning, she suggests asking a different question: What’s left? And what might still be beautiful?

KATE BOWLER: American culture in particular is obsessed with the idea that all pain has to be a lesson.

Purpose has become this cultural mania in which everyone needs to be doing something for a special reason. I call the obsession with purpose and its aftermath "the creation of purpose monsters." Purpose monsters are everywhere. Is this gonna work out? Is any of this a divine conspiracy to make me good?

We are itchy when we hear an unanswered question like that because it goes right to our material conditions, right to our fear, right to our ontological insecurity.

I think the idea that all pain has to teach us something is because spiritually we want an answer to the mystery. The mystery is, "why do bad things happen to good people?" We need an explanation for evil. And in the face of seeing anyone in pain, we want to be able to say, "I know why." But just because there's not a reason doesn't mean it's not meaningful.

Allowing ourselves the preciousness of the dignity of grief is both good and necessary. Beause when someone's telling you there's a lesson, it's as if they're saying, "I swear you didn't lose anything. Look around. It's all there." But we know in our hearts we're being lied to.

It's almost like that question just causes us to endlessly be looking backwards and, like, trying to rearrange the furniture of our past, when really we need a second to just say, "Alright, the floods came. What's left here for me to make something beautiful?"

Learn from the world's biggest thinkers.
  • Videos
    • Latest
    • The Big Think Interview
  • Columns
    • Mini Philosophy
    • Starts with a Bang
    • Big Think Books
    • The Long Game
    • Strange Maps
    • 13.8
    • The Well
    • Rethinking Possible
  • Sections
    • Philosophy
    • Mind & Behavior
    • Science & Tech
    • Business
    • History & Society
  • Classes
    • Class Library
  • Subscribe
    • Membership
    • Free Newsletters
  • Partner
    • Big Think+ Learning
    • Creative Studio
    • Advertise with Us
    • Events
  • More
    • About
    • Careers
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Sale
    • Accessibility
View our Twitter (X) feed View our Youtube channel View our Instagram feed View our Substack feed © Copyright 2007-2026 & BIG THINK, BIG THINK PLUS, SMARTER FASTER trademarks owned by Freethink Media, Inc. All rights reserved.

Related Articles

Today’s Wordle answer and hints for #1725 on March 10

Today’s Wordle answer and hints for #1725 on March 10

541 views

 ‘Connections’ answers and hints for today, March 10

‘Connections’ answers and hints for today, March 10

795 views

 "The fundamentals of FPS should drive our decision": Battlefield 6 designers say developers have a "responsibility" to make games intuitive

"The fundamentals of FPS should drive our decision": Battlefield 6 designers say developers have a "responsibility" to make games intuitive

914 views
Previous
Gretchen Rubin’s simple secrets for a happier, less cluttered life
Next
JWST peers inside a dying star’s “exposed cranium”